Why Every Small Business Needs an Incident Response Plan (And How to Build One)

Small businesses are increasingly in the crosshairs of cybercriminals. According to the 2024 Verizon Data Breach Investigations Report (DBIR), over 60% of small businesses experienced at least one cyberattack in the past year, with ransomware and credential theft among the top threats. Alarmingly, 95% of breaches affecting small businesses were financially motivated, showing that cybercriminals see small businesses as lucrative targets due to their often weaker security postures. Despite these risks, many small businesses lack the necessary Incident Response Plan (IRP) to mitigate attacks effectively.

The report highlights that more than half of small businesses struggle to detect and respond to security incidents in a timely manner, leading to severe financial and operational consequences, with a median financial loss of $50,000 per incident, as reported in the 2024 Verizon DBIR. Without a structured response, businesses face prolonged downtime, loss of customer trust, and potential regulatory penalties. Developing a proactive IRP ensures that small businesses can quickly contain threats, reduce damages, and recover operations with minimal disruption.

What Is an Incident Response Plan?

An Incident Response Plan (IRP) is a structured approach to detecting, responding to, and recovering from cybersecurity incidents. It ensures that your business can quickly contain threats, minimize damage, and resume normal operations with minimal disruption. According to the 2024 Verizon Data Breach Investigations Report (DBIR), the median response time for small businesses to detect and mitigate a cybersecurity incident is 72 hours, highlighting the need for a well-defined Incident Response Plan (IRP) to minimize potential damage. Without a well-defined IRP, businesses risk prolonged downtime, higher recovery costs, and potential legal liabilities. A well-executed IRP helps minimize cyber incidents’ financial and operational impact, ensuring resilience against future threats.

Why Your Small Business Needs an Incident Response Plan

  1. Minimizes Downtime: Cyberattacks can cripple operations, resulting in lost revenue and productivity. A well-structured IRP enables businesses to detect, contain, and remediate threats swiftly, ensuring systems return to normal operations as soon as possible. Proactively mitigating cyber threats can prevent extended business disruptions and financial setbacks.
  2. Reduces Financial Losses: The financial impact of a cyberattack on small businesses can be devastating. Many small businesses do not have the resources to absorb these losses, making it essential to have an IRP in place to minimize financial damage through quick response and mitigation efforts.
  3. Protects Customer Trust: Customer data is one of the most valuable assets of a business. A security breach can expose sensitive customer information, leading to lost trust and potential churn. Small businesses that demonstrate a proactive approach to cybersecurity through a well-prepared IRP are more likely to retain customer confidence and maintain their reputation in the marketplace.
  4. Ensures Legal Compliance: Many industries have strict data protection and cybersecurity regulations such as GDPR, HIPAA, and PCI-DSS. Failure to comply with these regulations can result in significant fines and legal consequences. Implementing an IRP helps businesses stay compliant by ensuring timely incident detection, reporting, and resolution, thereby reducing legal exposure and penalties.
  5. Provides a Clear Action Plan: Employees need clear guidelines on how to respond to cybersecurity incidents. Without an IRP, teams may struggle to make quick decisions during a crisis, leading to further damage. A well-documented IRP provides employees with step-by-step procedures, ensuring swift containment of threats, reducing panic, and maintaining business continuity.

How to Build an Effective Incident Response Plan

1. Identify Response Partners and Potential Threats

A strong Incident Response Plan (IRP) starts with identifying both potential cybersecurity threats and the key response partners who can assist in mitigating risks.

Response Partners: Having the right partners in place before an incident occurs ensures a swift and effective response. Key response partners may include managed security service providers (MSSPs), cybersecurity consultants, incident response teams, local law enforcement, and regulatory agencies. Establishing relationships with these partners ahead of time can significantly reduce response times and limit damage during an attack.

Potential Threats: Cyber threats vary depending on the industry, infrastructure, and digital footprint of your business. Common threats include phishing attacks, ransomware, insider threats, data breaches, and business email compromise (BEC). Understanding the likelihood and potential impact of these threats will help prioritize mitigation strategies.

By proactively identifying both threats and response partners, businesses can improve their preparedness and response effectiveness, ultimately minimizing disruptions and financial losses.

2. Establish Roles for Owners, Managers, and Staff

Each member of the organization plays a crucial role in responding to cybersecurity incidents. Clear role definition ensures that every team member understands their responsibilities, facilitating a swift and coordinated response.

Owners and Executives: Provide leadership, allocate resources, and establish policies to ensure cybersecurity preparedness. They also liaise with response partners such as managed security service providers (MSSPs) and law enforcement when needed.

Managers: Oversee the implementation of the Incident Response Plan (IRP), ensuring that staff are trained and response procedures are followed. They coordinate with legal and compliance teams to meet regulatory requirements.

Staff: Serve as the first line of defense by identifying and reporting suspicious activity. Employees should be trained to recognize phishing attempts, follow cybersecurity best practices, and act promptly in response to an incident.

Response Partners Integration: Businesses should work closely with external cybersecurity experts, incident response teams, and regulatory bodies to ensure a well-rounded approach to incident management. Establishing these relationships ahead of time ensures a faster, more effective response when an incident occurs.

3. Document Your Response Plan

A response plan does not truly exist unless it is well-documented, clear, and accessible to all relevant stakeholders. A comprehensive plan outlines the exact steps required for detecting, analyzing, containing, eradicating, and recovering from cybersecurity incidents.

Every individual and team identified in the previous steps—owners, managers, staff, and response partners—must be incorporated into the documented plan. Clearly define their roles, responsibilities, and specific actions they need to take in the event of an incident.

A well-documented plan should include:

  • How to detect an incident (e.g., security alerts, suspicious activity)
  • Immediate containment actions (e.g., isolating infected systems, disabling compromised accounts)
  • Strategies to eliminate the threat (e.g., deploying patches, removing malicious software)
  • Recovery steps to restore operations safely and efficiently

Additionally, the plan should specify reporting and escalation procedures, ensuring that communication is seamless between internal teams and external response partners. Keeping the plan up to date through regular reviews and updates is critical to maintaining its effectiveness.

4. Create a Communication Plan

A well-defined communication plan is essential to ensure a swift and coordinated response to cybersecurity incidents. Effective communication helps prevent misinformation, maintains customer trust, and ensures compliance with legal and regulatory requirements.

Internal Notification: Establish who should be informed first when an incident occurs. This should include key personnel such as owners, managers, and response partners identified in previous steps. The IRP should document who (owners or managers) can initiate the escalation process, ensuring that response teams, including MSSPs, cybersecurity consultants, and local law enforcement, are promptly engaged. A well-structured notification plan ensures a swift, coordinated response, allowing businesses to contain threats effectively and minimize potential damage.

External Communication: Determine how and when to notify customers, partners, and vendors if their data has been affected. Transparency is crucial in maintaining trust and reducing reputational damage. Craft pre-approved templates for notifications to ensure clarity and accuracy in messaging.

Regulatory Reporting: Many industries require businesses to report certain incidents to regulatory bodies such as the Federal Trade Commission (FTC), General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) authorities, or the Payment Card Industry Data Security Standard (PCI-DSS) compliance board. Identify the relevant regulations for your industry and outline the reporting procedures, including timeframes for disclosure.

This communication plan should integrate seamlessly with your response partners, including law enforcement, incident response teams, and legal advisors, ensuring that all communications are accurate, timely, and coordinated.

5. Implement Security Tools and Monitoring

Deploy firewalls, antivirus software, endpoint detection, and logging systems to enable you to detect and respond to threats in real-time. Ensure these security tools are configured and monitored by designated teams such as managed security service providers (MSSPs), identified in previous steps. Regularly update and test these tools to stay ahead of evolving cyber threats. Additionally, integrate security tools with incident response teams, cybersecurity consultants, and regulatory agencies to ensure real-time alerts and streamlined responses. Adequately training staff on security tools will further strengthen your organization’s cybersecurity posture, reducing the risk of breaches and enabling rapid containment when incidents occur.

6. Conduct Regular Training and Testing

Regular training and testing are critical to an effective Incident Response Plan (IRP). Businesses must ensure that their employees, managers, and response partners remain prepared to handle cybersecurity incidents effectively.

  • Train employees on cyber hygiene by providing ongoing education on identifying phishing attempts, securing sensitive data, and following security best practices. Employees are the first line of defense against cyber threats and must know how to recognize and report suspicious activities.
  • Test response tools and technologies to ensure they function correctly under real-world conditions. Security software, monitoring systems, and automated response tools must be regularly evaluated and updated to keep pace with evolving cyber threats.
  • Continuously update and refine your IRP based on lessons learned from training exercises and real-world incidents. Documenting insights from each training session helps improve response strategies, close security gaps, and strengthen the business’s overall resilience.

By integrating continuous training and testing, businesses can improve their ability to detect, contain, and mitigate cyber threats, ensuring a swift and effective response when an incident occurs.


A well-prepared Incident Response Plan is necessary for small businesses looking to safeguard their operations against cyber threats. The ability to detect, contain, and recover from a security incident using an IRP can mean the difference between a minor disruption and a devastating financial loss. With cyber threats on the rise and response times often lagging, having a well-documented and regularly tested IRP ensures that all team members, from owners and managers to staff and external response partners, know their roles and responsibilities during a crisis.

Proactively developing and testing an IRP can mitigate risks, reduce downtime, and protect your business’s future. Cybercriminals increasingly target small businesses due to perceived vulnerabilities, but you can stay ahead by taking a structured approach to incident response. Don’t wait until a breach happens—take action today.

Are you ready to build an IRP for your small business? Start by conducting a cybersecurity risk assessment, consulting with your response partners, and documenting a step-by-step action plan. Need help getting started? Contact cybersecurity professionals or explore free resources from trusted industry experts to guide you.

#VerizonDBIR, #DBIR2024, #CyberSecurity, #SmallBusiness, #IncidentResponse, #DataProtection, #CyberThreats, #CyberAttack, #RiskManagement, #SecurityAwareness, #CyberResilience, #BreachResponse, #InfoSec, #CyberDefense, #RansomwareProtection, #PhishingAwareness, #ITSecurity, #CyberRisk, #DataBreach, #ThreatDetection, #CyberStrategy, #SecurityBestPractices, #DigitalSecurity, #CyberPreparedness, #NetworkSecurity

Protect Your Small Business from Cyber Threats. Signup for our newsletter and ...

Download the Essential Cybersecurity Checklist Today!

We don’t spam! Read our privacy policy for more info.

After 30 years in the dynamic world of cybersecurity, I’m embracing a new chapter as a semi-retired professional. While I’ve traded the 9-to-5 grind for the freedom to explore personal passions (like scuba diving and traveling the globe), my enthusiasm for solving complex security challenges remains as strong as ever.

Today, I’m channeling my expertise into part-time opportunities, mentoring, and advisory roles. Whether it’s helping organizations fortify their security posture, guiding teams through crisis response, or mentoring the next generation of cybersecurity professionals, I’m here to make an impact.

Let’s connect! Whether you’re seeking a seasoned cybersecurity advisor, a mentor, or just someone to trade scuba stories with, I’d love to hear from you.

Leave a Comment